Design a site like this with
Get started

Review: Rosie Loves Jack by Mel Darbon


This was the first book I read for my reading challenge in January, where the theme was characters with a disability. Full disclosure, I pictured this one to be a sweet read about a girl with Down syndrome who goes on an adventure to find her boyfriend.

Nope. This book was so much more than that and it dived a lot deeper than I originally anticipated.

Parts of it showed how kind and compassionate humans can be, which made my heart swell in my chest. Other parts covered dark themes that, at times, were distressing and difficult to digest.

My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Genre: Young adult
Published on: 30 August 2018
Pages: 336 (paperback)
Published by: Usborne Publishing Ltd

Rating breakdown

Writing style/readability3.8
Diverse themes4.5

Rosie and Jack; two peas in a pod

Rose and Jack were meant to be. He makes the sun shine in her head and she calms his ‘angry’ . But sometimes, Jack’s ‘angry’ takes makes him do things he can’t control. After an incident at school, Jack is sent to Brighton and Rose is left alone. With no communication, she fears the worst, that Jack doesn’t love her anymore. Until she finds a pile of postcards from Jack that her father has hidden, hoping this will be the end to the relationship. With no other option, Rose secretly leaves for Brighton, desperate to bring Jack home. But the journey is far from smooth, and Rose meets some nice and some not so nice people who will do everything they can to stop her from getting to Jack.

An insight into the underbelly of London

Dropping a tiny spoiler here so jump to the next section if you don’t want to know what happens to Rose in London.

Last chance!

This isn’t a huge spoiler, more just it loses the shock factor if you know it’s coming. In London, Rose is approached by a man who says he can help her find Jack. Vulnerable and naïve, she is taken under his wing and finds herself in a trafficking home with other women (mostly underage).

Some people have called this out to be unrealistic but having learned about CSE (child-sexual exploitation) in a previous job, I can tell you that it’s much more common than people realise. It’s a theme that I’m very interested in exploring, particularly in novels as I feel like it get’s much less coverage than it should. It’s so prevalent, yet barely talked about in fiction or in reality. Everything that Rose, Lisette, and Courtney experienced is a reflection of real-life for many underage girls who maybe don’t fit in at home or are brainwashed by exploiters showering them with gifts and attention. It’s so easy to fall into the trap, and I thought the author explored this really really well.

(Spoiler end).

A well-rounded novel

Mel Darbon did a great job of injecting light-heartedness and acts of kindness into the story to counter the darker, more challenging themes without undermining them. There was hope throughout Rose’s difficult journey, and I wanted her to reach Jack so badly so they could reunite.

Rose’s Down syndrome made many people doubt her ability to be in-de-pen-dent but her unwavering strength and love for Jack kept her fighting. She was wonderfully developed and I gained a real insight into what it must be like for people with disabilities who know they are capable of more than people assume/give them credit for. Rose was often treated like a baby, although you could tell this was because her parents loved her and wanted to protect her. But I felt her anguish and the unfairness that she and Jack were unable to have the privacy they craved.

Perfect for older Jacqueline Wilson readers

Casting my mind way back to my childhood (who am I kidding, I love reading kids’ books as an adult), Rosie Loves Jack reminded me of a Jacqueline Wilson novel but for older readers. It was easy to get invested in the story and had a good flow, while still covering some challenging and difficult themes. Great for adults too, of course, and one I will definitely be recommending.

4 responses to “Review: Rosie Loves Jack by Mel Darbon”

  1. […] Rosie Loves Jack by Mel Darbon, recommended by @ReadingWithKT (character with Down syndrome) […]


  2. I’m glad to read your review of Rosie Loves Jack. I really enjoyed the book and had also thought it would be a sweet story so did find the plot disturbing at times and wondered about the validity of the storyline. However, reading your review has made me understand the trafficking part of the book better, thank you. I did feel at the end that I wanted an extension to know what had happened to the characters Rosie had met on her journey but a lovely ending anyway.


    1. Thank you so much for taking the time to read, it means a lot 😊 I was unsure about adding the spoiler but it’s a topic I’m very passionate about shedding light on. It’s scary how much trafficking and exploitation is under-reported, but it may be a safety thing for the children involved/not letting the trafficking rings know that the police are on to them. I agree, I really wanted more about Jack and his back-story, as well as the characters she met on the way!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: